Page's Saffin nails Cowper's Hartsuyker in the perennial Labor versus Nats battle

"Luke has lost the plot because he was proven incompetent in getting a solution to a problem in his electorate," she said.

"They are desperate actions of a desperate man.

"I'd be embarrassed if I had to get another MP to work out a solution in my electorate."

She said his petition was designed purely to seek political support for himself when a solution was already there."

Right on, Janelle! That poor excuse for a bill and the much-touted petition were always an embarrassment.

Everyone knew from past experience that the flying foxes would move on long before these would be considered - that working towards long term goals was the way to go if their seasonal return was to be made less of a problem for Maclean High School and nearby houses.

Hartsuyker didn't even bother tabling the petition until after the House of Reps adjourned at 7.30pm on 16th June 2010.

While his private member's bill very predictably sank without a trace after its

introduction on 15th March.