Australian Federal Election 2016: something is seriously wrong when private school students get more in government support than the government's own students

The Australian Constitution grants the Commonwealth no specific powers in relation to education. Nevertheless under Section 96 of the Constitution it has partially funded government and non-government schools since the Menzies era, with recurrent funding for private school students beginning in 1970 under Liberal Prime Minister John Gorton.

Some of these private schools belong to organizations holding considerable wealth. The Sydney Catholic archdiocese alone controls funds worth more than $1.2 billion and has regularly made multi-million dollar tax-free profits and nationally the Australian Catholic Church is thought to be worth an est. $100 billion.

On 18 May 2016 The Age reported on the growth in that federal government funding for non-government schools:

Something is seriously wrong when private school students get more in government support than the government's own students. Just as it is when private superannuants get more in government support than the government's own pensioners.

Yet it's happening, and neither side of politics wants to talk about it.

You can check out examples in your own suburb by scouring the MySchool website.

In Balwyn, the government-run Balwyn Primary gets $7214 of government funds per student, while down the road the privately run St Bede's Parish Primary gets $7974, plus what it charges parents.

In Preston, Newlands Primary gets $10,362 but Sacred Heart gets $11,488. In Spotswood, Spotswood Primary gets $8008 while St Margaret Mary's gets $11397. In Ballarat, Ballarat North Primary gets $8158 while St Patrick's gets $8499.

That's by no means a complete list, and the schools I have mentioned are roughly matched for size and socio-economic status.

Right now, on average, Catholic and independent private schools get less per student than government schools, but if present trends continue they'll overtake government schools in four years. An analysis by a former president of the NSW Secondary Principals Council, Chris Bonnor, and education researcher Bernie Shepherd entitled Private School, Public Cost finds that by 2020 the typical Catholic student will receive $850 more than the typical government student, and the typical independent student $100 more.

In the Lower Clarence Valley (Page electorate) on the NSW North Coast similar examples can be found.

St. James Primary School, Yamba NSW – total enrolments 102 pupils

Net recurrent income 2014			$ Total					$ Per student
		Australian Government recurrent funding		969,340					10,536
		State/territory government recurrent funding		207,246					2,253
		Fees, charges and parent contributions		98,101					1,066
		Other private sources		55,836					607
		Total gross income (excluding income from government capital grants)			1,330,523			14,462

Yamba Public School, Yamba NSW- total enrolment 386 pupils

Net recurrent income 2014			$ Total					$ Per student
		Australian Government recurrent funding		607,352					1,586
		State/territory government recurrent funding		3,030,464					7,912
		Fees, charges and parent contributions		86,124					225
		Other private sources		7,982					21
		Total gross income (excluding income from government capital grants)			3,731,922				9,744

St Joseph's PrimarySchool, Maclean, NSW - total enrolments 103 pupils

Net recurrent income 2014				$ Total					$ Per  student
			Australian Government recurrent funding		1,346,008				9,970
			State/territory government recurrent funding		540,393				4,003
			Fees, charges and parent contributions		150,565				1,115
			Other private sources		56,717				420
			2,093,683							15,509

MacleanPublic School, Maclean, NSW - total enrolments 183 pupils

Net recurrent income 2014			$ Total							$ Per student
		Australian Government recurrent funding		366,999				1,932
		State/territory government recurrent funding		1,738,097				9,148
		Fees, charges and parent contributions		61,132				322
		Other private sources		42,194				222
		Total gross income (excluding income from government capital grants)			2,208,421				11,623