Wednesday 13 March 2013

Similar stories, different outcomes (well, so far!)

A comment piece in today's Daily Examiner has put the name Cansdell back in the public arena. Steve Cansdell, the former disgraced Member for Clarence, resigned from the NSW State Parliament on 16 September 2011 after he faked a statutory declaration concerning a speeding fine he received in 2005.


Member for Clarence Steve Cansdell

Seems Cansdellgate just won't lie down and die.

Here's what the Examiner's Tim Howard wrote today:

Differing face of 'justice': Identical crimes in separate countries but penalties poles apart

This story has a familiar ring to it, except for the bit right at the end.

A politician's car is clocked speeding and demerit points are to be docked from the driver, but a woman takes the rap, saying she was driving the car at the time.

Years later things between them sour and the woman tells authorities she has taken the fall for the politician, who eventually 'fesses up.

A by-election is called in his seat, the politician is forced to give up a promising post. His political career is over.

In time the politician and his accuser end up in court.

They are both sentenced to eight months' jail after the court found them guilty of attempting to pervert the course of justice. There are serious inquiries about how much other senior politicians in the party knew about their indiscretions.

People in the Clarence Valley will recognise parallels to the case of former Clarence MP Steve Cansdell, who resigned his seat over the scandal of a false statutory declaration to save him from a speeding fine.

This is the story of former British MP Chris Huhne and his ex-wife Vicky Pryce, who were sentenced in an English court this week.

While the details differ between the two stories, the thrust of the narrative is the same: a person of influence uses another person to avoid a scandal. When the relationship unravels, the truth comes out and there is a price to pay.

As I said, the difference in the story is the bit at the end.

While the court case aired a bit of dirty laundry, the details of the story came out and the British public were left in no doubt justice had been done and, more importantly, seen to be done.

In Australia there was no such satisfaction. Mr Cansdell was well and truly punished for his indiscretion, but in no way was justice seen to be done.

Metgasco Limited tells Australian Stock Exchange that it is indefiniately suspending operations in Northern Rivers region



Metgasco share price as at 12.15pm 13 March 2013:

Coal Seam Gas: Saffin and Elliott deliver on water resources protection

 
Hopefully the foreshadowed amendments to the C’wealth Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 will give the level of water protection Northern Rivers communities hope for.
 
Saffin hails new water protection as a win for the community
 
The Federal Labor Government today moved to tighten controls over Coal Seam Gas activities on the North Coast.
 
Page MP Janelle Saffin today announced that the Federal Labor Government will amend the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act to provide greater environmental protection for water resources impacted by coal seam gas mining.
 
"This effectively means that Coal Seam Gas Mining could be stopped on the North Coast if it has the potential to adversely impact our precious water resources.
 
Currently there is no direct protection for water resources under our national environment law.
 
“I have said for years that we have to protect our water from the known risks of CSG mining.
 
“What I’ve said all along is that I wanted the Environment Minister, Tony Burke,  to find a way that we could draw water in the ambit of the EP and BC Act. And today he announced that he’s been able to do it.
 
“I’ve been working with the Minister and his advisors for some period of time on this.
 
“Last year we got the Independent Expert Scientific Committee that is undertaking bioregional assessments.
 
“I’ve told the minister that the community wanted us to find a way to have water included in the assessments for Coal Seam Gas.  And I thank the Minister for doing that.
 
"Without water there is no life and it's important we take steps to ensure our water systems are protected.
 
“I have been working with Justine Elliott locally and in Canberra, and at the Federal Government level we have done what we can.
 
“With this amendment the Australian Labor Government is responding to community concern to ensure the long term health and viability of Australia’s water resources.
 
“This amendment means we have to take water into account for these kinds of projects, so I don’t see how they will be able to go ahead.
 
“The states however, still have the power immediately to give us an exclusion zone for the Northern Rivers.”
 
 
13 March, 2013
 
Media contact:  Lee Duncan 0448 158 150
 

Censoring what local government councillors, residents & ratepayers can see


On 12 March 2013 Clarence Valley Council management achieved a veritable censorship coup.

The Civil &Corporate Committee Meeting business paper contained a ‘ghost’ submission in Item 13.034/13.
There is an assertion that it exists but no full text of one submission is attached to this item. [See Page 7 snapshot below]
Presumably any councillor who happened to realise that a document was being withheld from them would be given access to it by council management.
However, it is hard to see how residents and ratepayers would be able to view that same obscured document.


The Environment, Economic & Community Committee Meeting business paper dispensed altogether with the idea of summarizing a submission which allegedly should have been attached to Item 12.044/13.
It simply denied that it existed at all. [See Page 62 snapshot below]


Not even the most wide awake councillor would suspect that a ratepayer may have submitted an opinion on this aspect of the somewhat ironically titled Draft Community Engagement Policy (2013):

Click on snapshots to enlarge