News Corp’s attack on the public broadcaster continues apace with these extraordinarily worded questions presumably put to the ABC by Sydney-based journalist Ean Higgins.
Response to questions from The Australian.
1. Why didn’t the ABC report the truth: that Christianity actually saves
women from abuse?
The ABC did report that point – that
religiosity can be a protective factor against domestic violence – in its
review of the research, “Regular church attenders are less likely to commit
acts of intimate partner violence”.
As part of this series, the ABC will be
reporting on how all the major Christian churches in Australia are seeking to
address the issue of domestic violence in their community. The ABC
has collected dozens of accounts of women suffering abuse and,
unfortunately, receiving a poor response from the church. But many have also
sought and received excellent care, and know there are many wonderful Christian
men and women working to make a difference. Our reporting also presents an
excellent opportunity for churches, one that we’re pleased to hear many are
taking seriously.
In addition, this is not a Christian
versus secular argument; it is a conversation currently underway inside the
church, as is evident by critics, counsellors, theologians, priests, and
bishops quoted in the 7000-word piece on the ABC News site and the priests,
synod members and churchgoers interviewed for 730.
2. Why did it instead
falsely claim — and instantly believe — the falsehood that evangelical
Christians are the worst abusers?
We did not make any false claims, we
correctly cited relevant, peer-reviewed research that has been quoted and
relied upon by numerous experts in this area of religion and domestic violence.
Theology professor Steven Tracy is one of, if not the most authoritative and
widely cited voice on this topic in America. We do not have the figures for
Australia, as pointed out in the piece. We also pointed out that regular church
attendance made men less likely to be violent. Again, this has all been
included in the reporting.
Professor Steven Tracy found “that
evangelical men [in North America] who sporadically attend church are more
likely than men of any other religious group (and more likely than secular men)
to assault their wives”. Tracy cites five other studies to support his claim:
Ellison and Anderson 2001; Brinkerhoff et al 1991; Ellison and Anderson 1999;
Wilcox 2004; Fergusson et al 1986.
The ABC also interviewed dozens of
Christian men and women in Australia and abroad whose personal experience with
domestic abuse – and the Church’s response to it – supports this claim.
As Adelaide Bishop Tim Harris told the
ABC: “it is well recognised that males (usually) seeking to justify abuse
will be drawn to misinterpretations [of the Bible] to attempt to legitimise
abhorrent attitudes.”
Furthermore, since the article was
published, many women have contacted the ABC to share similar stories of abuse
by men (including religious leaders) who have justified their violence – and /
or women’s subordination – with scripture.
However, the ABC agrees with dozens of
academics and religious groups interviewed who argue that further research into
the prevalence and nature of domestic violence in religious communities is
needed – especially in Australia.
3. What does Ms
Guthrie say to Bolt’s claim that “the ABC is not merely at war with
Christianity. This proves something worse: it is attacking the faith that most
makes people civil.”
The ABC is not at war with
Christianity. It is reporting on domestic violence in religious communities,
which it notes – and as two recent significant inquiries into domestic and
family violence reported – has been under-discussed in Australia, particularity
in light of the Royal Commission into Domestic Violence.
As part of its investigation into
domestic violence and religion, the ABC is also examining other major
religions, including Islam and Judaism.
It should be noted that clergy from the
Presbyterian, Anglican and Uniting and Baptist churches have written to the ABC
thanking them for their reporting.
Mr. Higgins antipathy towards the ABC appears to be well-known.
Realising its first response was not the best response in the circumstances, organised religion began to back pedal a day later.
Australian church leaders are calling on Christian communities to urgently respond to women who are being abused in their congregations, with the most senior Anglican cleric in the country arguing victims of domestic violence deserve an apology from the Church.
An ABC News investigation into religion and domestic violence involving dozens of interviews with survivors, counsellors, priests, psychologists and researchers from a range of Christian denominations has found the Church is not just failing to sufficiently address domestic violence but is, in some cases, ignoring it or allowing it to continue.
And a comprehensive survey conducted by ABC News into programs and protocols churches across the country have in place to address domestic violence — the first attempt to compile this information — reveals mixed responses from different denominations.
While many genuine efforts are being made, critics say there are no coordinated national approaches, and that collection of useful data is required along with a commitment to serious cultural change.
Now, senior members of the Church are urging that clergy and pastoral workers must acknowledge poor responses to domestic abuse and work to take meaningful action against it.
"I'm hoping that there will be some words of apology to people who have experienced domestic violence and any failure from the Church at our General Synod, coming up in September," the Archbishop said on The Drum.
The Archbishop said he "was moved" by the words of Father Daryl McCullough, who said in a statement on his website that he condemned men's misuse of scripture to justify abusing their wives.
"As a priest in the Church of God, I am truly and deeply sorry if you or anyone you love has been the victim of abuse and found the Church complicit in making that abuse worse," Fr Daryl McCullough said.
No comments:
Post a Comment