Wednesday, 11 April 2018
It seems climate change deniers may be looking to that far-right lobby group the Insitute of Public Affairs (IPA) to organise defence fund appeals in the future
For more
than a decade, Ridd
[Peter Vincent Ridd] has been happily criticising the science linking dangerous climate
change to greenhouse gas emissions and the science showing the impacts of
humans on corals.
Ridd has also
repeatedly, over many years, said that the impact of agricultural runoff and
water quality on the health and growth rate of corals is overstated.
But his employer, James
Cook University, initiated its own action against Ridd after he had criticised
specific organisations at his own university in media interviews, saying they
could not be trusted. This, the university alleged, went against the
university’s code of conduct.
So this is not about
Ridd’s “freedom” to say what he wants but is about an alleged breach of
the university’s code of conduct — whether you agree with that code
or not.
When the university
censured Ridd in 2016, he ignored them. He gave an interview
in August 2017 to another climate science denier, Alan Jones, on Sky News.
Ridd was there to talk about his chapter in a climate science denial book produced by the Institute
of Public Affairs (IPA).
Ridd said 'we
can no longer trust' the Government-backed Australian Institute of Marine Scienceand
the Center of Excellence for Coral
Reef Studies, based at James Cook University…..
The university alleged
this constituted further “serious misconduct”, so Ridd took the issue to his
lawyers and a case is proceeding.
To help fund his legal
bills, Ridd got some help from the IPA (a key organisation pushing
climate science denial in Australia for two decades) to set up a crowdfunding
campaign that raised the necessary $95,000 in just 49 hours.
The IPA’s executive
director John Roskam was
the first donor with $500. Other notable givers included climate science denier
and blogger Anthony
Watts, U.S. Interior Department employee
and climate science denier Indur Goklany, Perth
philanthropist and IPA funder Bryant Macfie and author and political
scientist Don Aitken. The Washington Post and others have also reported how
Goklany has had a key role in re-writing Department of Interior
climate documents.
Many of Ridd’s
cheerleaders have taken his scientific claims without scepticism and have not
entertained the idea that he might be wrong.
Ridd’s marine pollution?
But Ridd repeated in
detail several of his criticisms in a November 2017 "viewpoint" article in the journal Marine
Pollution Bulletin — opening up his arguments for scrutiny.
Now, as reported in The Guardian Australia, a team
of nine scientists, many based at the Australian Institute of Marine Science
and the James Cook University centre Ridd has attacked, have issued a response through the same journal. Their
assessment of Ridd’s claims is sharp.
They say Ridd’s
criticisms are based on 'misinterpretation, selective use of data and
over-simplification' and that they ignore 'formal responses to
previously published critiques'.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment