Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Sunday 31 July 2016
Young Libs foul their political nest again
The Sydney Morning Herald, 29 July 2016:
This article excerpt was removed due to a confidential defamation settlement between Fairfax and unidentified parties.
Note that the details of this web address registration were altered on 28 July 2016
Labels:
education,
jobs,
Liberal Party of Australia,
scam
Tuesday 24 May 2016
Australian Federal Election 2016: something is seriously wrong when private school students get more in government support than the government's own students
The Australian
Constitution grants the Commonwealth no specific powers in relation
to education. Nevertheless under Section 96 of the Constitution it has partially
funded government and non-government schools since the Menzies era, with recurrent funding for private school students beginning in 1970 under Liberal Prime
Minister John Gorton.
Some of these private schools belong to organizations holding considerable wealth. The Sydney Catholic archdiocese alone controls funds worth more than $1.2 billion and has regularly made multi-million dollar tax-free profits and nationally the Australian Catholic Church is thought to be worth an est. $100 billion.
On 18 May
2016 The
Age reported on the growth in that federal government funding for non-government
schools:
Something is seriously
wrong when private school students get more in government support than the
government's own students. Just as it is when private superannuants get more in
government support than the government's own pensioners.
Yet it's happening, and
neither side of politics wants to talk about it.
You can check out
examples in your own suburb by scouring the MySchool website.
In Balwyn, the government-run
Balwyn Primary gets $7214 of government funds per student, while down the road
the privately run St Bede's Parish Primary gets $7974, plus what it charges
parents.
In Preston, Newlands
Primary gets $10,362 but Sacred Heart gets $11,488. In Spotswood, Spotswood
Primary gets $8008 while St Margaret Mary's gets $11397. In Ballarat, Ballarat
North Primary gets $8158 while St Patrick's gets $8499.
That's by no means a complete
list, and the schools I have mentioned are roughly matched for size and
socio-economic status.
Right now, on average,
Catholic and independent private schools get less per student than government
schools, but if present trends continue they'll overtake government schools in
four years. An analysis by a former president of the NSW Secondary Principals
Council, Chris Bonnor, and education researcher Bernie Shepherd entitled Private
School, Public Cost finds that by 2020 the typical Catholic student
will receive $850 more than the typical government student, and the typical
independent student $100 more.
In the Lower Clarence Valley (Page electorate) on the NSW North Coast similar examples can be found.
Net recurrent income 2014
|
$ Total
|
$ Per student
|
|||||||
Australian Government recurrent
funding
|
969,340
|
10,536
|
|||||||
State/territory government recurrent
funding
|
207,246
|
2,253
|
|||||||
Fees, charges and parent
contributions
|
98,101
|
1,066
|
|||||||
Other private sources
|
55,836
|
607
|
|||||||
Total gross income
(excluding income from government capital grants) |
1,330,523
|
14,462
|
|||||||
Net recurrent income 2014 |
$ Total
|
$ Per student
|
||||||||
Australian Government recurrent
funding
|
607,352
|
1,586
|
||||||||
State/territory government recurrent
funding
|
3,030,464
|
7,912
|
||||||||
Fees, charges and parent
contributions
|
86,124
|
225
|
||||||||
Other private sources
|
7,982
|
21
|
||||||||
Total gross income
(excluding income from government capital grants) |
3,731,922
|
9,744
|
||||||||
Net recurrent income 2014
|
$ Total
|
$ Per
student
|
|||||||||
Australian Government recurrent
funding
|
1,346,008
|
9,970
|
|||||||||
State/territory government recurrent
funding
|
540,393
|
4,003
|
|||||||||
Fees, charges and parent
contributions
|
150,565
|
1,115
|
|||||||||
Other private sources
|
56,717
|
420
|
|||||||||
2,093,683
|
15,509
|
||||||||||
Net recurrent income 2014
|
$ Total
|
$ Per student
|
||||||||||
Australian Government recurrent
funding
|
366,999
|
1,932
|
||||||||||
State/territory government recurrent
funding
|
1,738,097
|
9,148
|
||||||||||
Fees, charges and parent
contributions
|
61,132
|
322
|
||||||||||
Other private sources
|
42,194
|
222
|
||||||||||
Total gross income
(excluding income from government capital grants) |
2,208,421
|
11,623
|
||||||||||
Sunday 15 May 2016
Australian Federal Election 2016: spot Amanda Vanstone's attempts at political deception in The Age newspaper
This was former Liberal Senator for South Australia and former minister in the Howard Government, Amanda Vanstone writing in The Age on 9 May 2016 in an article titled Turnbull or Shorten? The choice seems clear:
Let’s break that down a little.
Schooling
Yes, Malcolm Turnbull went to a public primary school at Vaucluse in Sydney’s affluent Eastern Suburbs for about three years and, yes he went to Sydney Grammar School from the age of eight with the assistance of a scholarship for at least part of that period. He graduated from university during the years when undergraduate and post-graduate tertiary education was free of course fees in Australia. He was the child of divorced parents. All this is on the public record.
Bill Shorten went to a local Catholic primary school before attending Xavier College’s junior & senior schools in the Eastern Suburbs of Melbourne – his mother taught at Xavier and presumably there was some degree of discount on his school fees. So yes, he also had a private education in affluent suburbs. He graduated from university during the years when tertiary education was free of course fees and undertook a post-graduate degree during a period when course fees were re-instituted. His parents divorced when he was about 20 years of age. All of which is also on the public record.
Wealth
Malcolm Turnbull inherited assets worth an est. $2 million from his hotel-broker father before he turned 29 years of age according to one of his biographers Paddy Manning and, he and his wife independently and jointly went on to garner considerably greater wealth which was last estimated to be in the vicinity of $200 million. His last Statement of Registrable Interests lists a veritable slew of financial investments and an expensive property portfolio shared between he and his wife. It is not known if he inherited any money from his mother.
It is not known to the writer if Bill Shorten inherited any money to speak of from his dry-dock manager father or his mother, however his last Statement of Registrable Interests lists very little in assets held by either he or his wife beyond their mortgaged family home.
What essentially separates these two men are the differences in their personal and political philosophies and the wide gap between their different levels of personal wealth.
Although this is something Amanda Vanstone is trying hard to distort in this federal election campaign and something The Age appears to be so indifferent to that its editor is not reigning in her excesses.
Monday 9 May 2016
THE NATIONALS SAY THEY WANT TO HEAR FROM ELECTORS
Some weeks
ago people in the Northern Rivers – and presumably other parts of the country –
received an email from Fiona Nash, the Nationals’ Deputy Leader. Ms Nash stated that she was committed to
giving regional Australians a proper voice at the top table and wanted help in
representing us.
She continued
with: “The new Deputy Prime Minister,
Barnaby Joyce and I are renewing our commitment to people in small towns, on
family farms and small communities. Those on our pristine coast, and deep in
the bush. We will fight every day for the hospitals, roads and essential
services regional people deserve. Our party, uniquely, has never forgotten who
we represent – and who we work for. This is your chance to tell us what YOU
think we should be prioritising in 2016.”
The person
who told me about the email was rather bemused that she had received such a
communication from the Nationals.
However, she decided that, since she had emailed the local federal MP
about an issue some time ago, that must have been how her email address was
obtained.
A MESSAGE TO FIONA NASH - SOME VIEWS ON THREE OF THE ISSUES THE
NATIONALS SHOULD PRIORITISE
EDUCATION
Gonski should be fully funded until
2020. The Gonski education reforms which provide needs-based funding are about
fairness and equal opportunity in education – of vital importance to our
national future – particularly a future in which we have been told innovation
will be important.
Needs-based
resourcing for education is extremely important in rural areas which often
suffer from socio-economic disadvantage.
Before the
2013 election there was a bipartisan commitment to full Gonski funding – something the Government has since
reneged on. This is one of a number of
promises broken by the Coalition following that election.
Some time ago
the Prime Minister suggested public schools funding could become the sole
responsibility of the states. This justifiably
angered many community members who support public schools and believe they
perform a vital role in our society. The Commonwealth must continue to share
responsibility for public school funding.
HEALTH
There is considerable room for
improvement in dealing with health issues in regional areas. For example hospitals are often poorly
equipped and funded; mental health services are lacking in many areas; and
specialist services are minimal except in the larger regional centres. It is often difficult to attract and keep GPs
in rural areas – let alone specialists.
The Medical
Research and Rural Health Garvan Report 2015 pointed out that people
living in rural and remote areas make up
30% of the population but do not receive anywhere near 30% of health funding.
A recent article in The
Daily Examiner, the Clarence Valley’s daily newspaper, discussed the major health issues in the Clarence and
the fact that local residents are disadvantaged in relation to preventative
health care as well as in obtaining medical assistance for health emergencies.
(Saturday April 30th)
CLIMATE CHANGE
Climate change is a major and urgent issue which has been woefully
neglected by the Coalition Government.
It’s not surprising that the Nationals have been dragging their heels
when Deputy Leader Fiona Nash claims the science isn’t settled – and she obviously
isn’t the only climate sceptic in the party.
Despite these views, the Nationals need to realize that an increasing
number of Australians – including those in regional areas – are very concerned
about climate change and the impact it is already having in Australia and
elsewhere. And that number is going to
rise. There will be an increasing demand
from the electorate for effective measures to limit carbon emissions and to
transition to renewable energy. This
transition has huge benefits for our economy and for jobs – benefits that the
Government is recklessly ignoring.
Just how much do the Nationals know about the potential benefits that
renewable energy can bring – and is already bringing – to rural areas? Are the National aware of moves towards
setting up community energy projects?
Are they aware of Enova, the new energy retailer being established in
the Northern Rivers? As well as knowing
about these developments, they should be enthusiastically supporting them. These are examples of important innovations
and ones the Government as a whole should be supporting.
SO,
FIONA NASH, RURAL
PEOPLE DESERVE ACTION ON
THESE MATTERS. ARE
YOU AND YOUR
COLLEAGUES GOING TO
FIGHT FOR THEM ?
Hildegard
Northern Rivers
6th May 2016
GuestSpeak is a feature of North
Coast Voices allowing Northern Rivers residents to make satirical or
serious comment on issues that concern them. Posts of 250-300 words or less can
be submitted to ncvguestspeak AT gmail.com.au for
consideration. Longer posts will be considered on topical subjects.
Thursday 28 April 2016
Australian Federal Election 2016: the face of private education
A report card on private education in Australia......
The New Daily, 25 March 2015:
More than 40 per cent of Australian secondary children now attend private schools – either so-called independent or religious schools. Australia has one of the most privatised school systems in the OECD….
New figures from the Productivity Commission show that government funding increases between 2008-09 and 2012-13 massively favoured private schools over public schools.
Funding for private schools in Victoria, for example, increased by 18.5 per cent per student, or eight times that of public schools.
Across Australia, the dollar increase for private schools was nearly five times that for public schools. The average increase for private schools was A$1,181 per student compared to only A$247 for public schools.
Other research indicates clearly that the equity gap between our school systems has continued to grow since the Gonski review in 2011.
Each private school pupil now receives, on average, a non-means-tested public subsidy of over A$8000 per year at the expense of the less privileged public school student. So much for the end of the age of entitlement.
In addition, pupils with disabilities in public schools receive A$12,000 of extra support while those in private schools get over A$30,000.
The Conversation, 24 April 2015:
PISA results from 2012 show that independent schools do better than Catholic schools, which in turn do better than government schools. However, when school-level socioeconomic background is taken into account, the differences in performance across school sectors are not significant.
A recent study by researchers at UQ, Curtin and USQ has allowed the simmering educational debate to come to the boil again. Drawing on data from the Longitudinal Study of Australian Children, it finds that sending children to Catholic or other independent primary schools has no significant effect on cognitive or non-cognitive outcomes.
What is interesting is that researchers aligned this study with evidence from the US and UK and were able to draw the same conclusions. That is, for students attending non-government schools the returns are no different to public schools.
The Australian, 6 July 2015:
Taxpayer funding for private schools has grown twice as fast as for government schools, official data reveals.
Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority statistics show that federal, state and territory government funding for independent and Catholic schools grew by 23 per cent, on a per-student basis, between 2009 and 2013.
Taxpayer funding to government schools grew by just 12.5 per cent over the same period.
Taxpayers contributed $11,864 for each student in government schools, $9547 for those in Catholic schools and $7790 for other private school students in 2013.
Private school fees and donations boosted the total net recurrent income per student to $12,548 per government school student, $12,177 per Catholic student and $16,601 per private student, on average, in 2013.
The Conversation, 9 July 2015:
The Advertiser,11 November 2015:
ELITE Adelaide private school Prince Alfred College has been found liable for the sexual abuse of one of its students by a boarding master in the 1960s.
The Sydney Morning Herald, 6 January 2016:
A Sydney private school has been accused of underpaying its employees by the Independent Education Union.
Reddam House, headquartered in Sydney's eastern suburbs, faced the Fair Work Commission in December over allegations that it had not paid some of its early learning staff overtime, penalties or provided them with pay slips.
The allegations relate to a "state of the art early learning centre" that the 800-student school established on the north shore, last year.
The Reddam ELS centre for children aged between one and six years features "interactive piazza spaces, critical thinking studios and breakout areas", the Reddam House website says.
Despite Reddam's promotion of the early learning centre based in St Leonards as "one of the highlights of 2015", the school said the early learning staff were never employed by Reddam itself, a K-12 institution that earned $18 million in student fees last year.
Reddam's barrister, Christopher Parkin, told the commission that the staff were employed by Crawford Education Pty Ltd and were therefore not subject to the award agreements negotiated between Reddam House and the IEU.
The Sydney Morning Herald, 11 February 2016:
Thousands of students of at least four colleges have been left in limbo with huge debts following the collapse of one of the country's largest vocational education companies.
At least 500 administration and teaching staff have also been affected by the collapse.
Aspire College of Education, The Design Works College of Design, RTO Services Group and the Australian Indigenous College were placed in voluntary administration on Tuesday. Aspire alone has about 20 campuses around Australia.
All of the colleges are owned by Global Intellectual Holdings, which is also in administration with debt owing to ANZ Bank.
The fallout follows a federal government crackdown on the scandal-plagued vocational education sector, which included bans on inducements like free laptops and freezing funds to private colleges accessing VET FEE-HELP to 2015 levels.
There has been widespread rorting of VET FEE-HELP, a HECS-style loans system for vocational training students…..
Global Intellectual Holdings made $83 million in revenue in the year to June 2015, making it one of the largest vocational education companies in Australia.
The group's collapse comes despite Global Intellectual Holdings making a profit of $17.95 million in 2015. During the year it paid $14 million in dividends to its directors Roger Williams and Aloi Burgess. The accounts show the company held $19 million in debt.
News.com.au, 31 March 2016:
The Prime Minister said there was “a very powerful case” for giving state governments total responsibility for payments to state schools from income tax revenue, while the Commonwealth funded private education, such as Catholic schools….
Mr Turnbull’s proposal was among suggestions made in the Reforming the Federation white paper delivered to the Federal Government last year.
It’s options included give states and territories complete funding responsibility for education; and limiting federal spending to independent schools while states and territories fully fund public schools.
The Sydney Morning Herald, 4 April 2016:
On Monday, the Malek Fahd Islamic school in Greenacre lost an appeal to have $19 million in federal government funding reinstated.
The decision came after a Federal Department of Education investigation found the private school was operating for profit following allegations of six-figure loans to board members while basic services went unfunded…..
The decision from the Federal Department of Education means funding will dry up by Friday, the last day of term. Despite being a private institution, the school and five others operated by AFIC rely on public funding for 75 per cent of their income.
ABC News, 5 April 2016:
Some of Australia's most prestigious private schools are being sued for millions of dollars by men who allege they were sexually abused by teachers and staff.
Sydney lawyer Ross Koffel is bringing multiple claims for damages in the NSW Supreme Court against schools including The Scots College, Knox Grammar, Waverley College and De La Salle, Revesby Heights.
Mr Koffel told the ABC he had been approached by a large number of men who allege they were abused at private schools around the country.
"It just seemed to me to be the same problem in school after school after school and it surprised us how many schools, how many students are affected," Mr Koffel said.
"It is a systemic problem in the institutions, in the schools. We're alleging sexual abuse of the students during school hours in most cases and on the school premises, and it just really couldn't be worse."
Ten separate claims against The Scots College, Knox Grammar, Waverley College and De La Salle College, Revesby Heights have been lodged and another two claims will be lodged in coming months.
Mr Koffel said he is investigating another eight claims against other schools.
The Sydney Morning Herald, 11 April 2016:
Twenty of Sydney's wealthiest private schools received $111 million in taxpayer funding last year, new data has revealed, allowing the institutions to subsidise plans for tennis courts, flyover theatre towers, and Olympic pools with underwater cameras.
The schools, including The King's School, Trinity Grammar and SCECGS Redlands, have offset parents investments through the public purse courtesy of an $11 million increase in combined state and federal funding since 2012, according to MySchool data.
On Friday, Fairfax Media revealed that the oldest girls school in Australia, St Catherine's in Waverley, had won a battle to build a $63 million auditorium complete with an orchestra pit, a water polo pool, and a flyover tower for state-of-the-art theatre productions…..
It is illegal for private schools to invest recurrent funding in building works, but the public injections allow schools to produce savings in their recurrent staff budgets, and direct school fees and donations towards capital projects, where they can also receive separate dedicated capital funding from the government.
The Sydney Morning Herald, 20 April 2016:
More than 20 federal police officers raided Australian Careers Network last week after 16,000 students were left in limbo and hundreds of jobs were lost at the company. The action came after the ACCC launched action in the Federal Court in November against one of ACN's colleges to recover $106 million in taxpayer funding,
The ACCC has alleged the college acted unconscionably in enrolling students with intellectual disabilities and preying on people in Aboriginal communities while enrolling them in up to $18,000 in public debt. It also allegedly signed them up to online courses despite not having access to the internet.
The allegations could help to explain why Boston Consulting found ACN to be 224 per cent more efficient than TAFE in its use of physical assets.
The Sydney Morning Herald, 25 April 2016:
The multi-millionaire chief executive of an embattled private training empire has been accused of running a bizarre harassment campaign against a senior police officer during his former career as a cop on the Bass Coast.
Ivan Brown co-founded the Australian Careers Network.....
Before Mr Brown was propelled onto the BRW Young Rich List in 2014 with a stake in an estimated $177 million fortune, he worked as policeman in Wonthaggi. But the extraordinary circumstances of his departure from the force have never been made public.
Fairfax Media can reveal Mr Brown was the subject of an internal investigation by the former Ethical Standards Department over claims he launched a vindictive bullying campaign against Senior Sergeant Steve Gibson in 2009…..
Thursday 21 April 2016
Australian Federal Election 2016: genes are destiny excuse
Journalist Jennifer Oriel in The Australian on 11 April 2016, putting the case for a two-tiered national education system where public schools and their 'dumb' students living in comparative poverty are offered less opportunity because genetics are allegedly destiny:
More punitive taxes and
big spender social programs in education and health are central pillars of ALP
plans for fiscal repair. The former is aimed at reducing the deficit Labor
increased by squandering the proceeds of the mining boom. It wasted billions on
cash splashes and social programs that have failed to achieve stated policy
goals in improving educational and social outcomes. Now the party needs a
scapegoat. The politics of envy provides an endless supply…..
Whether the object of
envy is intelligence, talent, beauty, status or wealth, there is always a group
that feels entitled to what nature or nurture did not provide. If they cannot
take the envied trait or property by force, the envious seek to deride those
who bear it.
As a unifying political
device, the emotion of envy has few equals. In Australia, it finds social form
in the tall poppy syndrome. Visitors to Australia long have remarked upon the
darker side envy amplifies in our national character.….
Modern Labor began its
campaign against Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull by sowing envy about his
wealth and international investments. But the collective envy required to
justify a circular regimen of Keynesian redistribution demands a collective
target and policy goals that are always just out of reach, either because they
are unattainable or conveniently unquantifiable. Equality of outcome is the
substantive socialist solution.
While liberals support
equal opportunity and formal equality, socialists engineer equality of outcome
through policy prescriptions increasingly at odds with science. Labor’s
education policy is a case in point. In a letter to school principals last
week, Bill Shorten committed to redressing inequality by promising money the government
doesn’t have to fund Gonski education reforms. Despite the sound aim of
improving the educational outcomes of all children, at a cost of $37.3 billion,
delivering the Gonksi policy through government inflicts a heavy toll on the
taxpayer with doubtful return on investment. Numerous private companies provide
high efficacy literacy and numeracy programs while decades of government-run
interventions have had little impact in levelling educational outcomes. And
recent research indicates the Gonski reform package, like numerous social
programs before it, is unlikely to succeed.
Despite Labor’s
education revolution and promises of substantive equality, vast differences in
educational outcomes continue. The most recent research suggests a reason for
inequality of educational attainment that should provoke a rethink of social
and economic policy. Speaking on SBS’s Insight program, Brian Byrne
of the University of New England revealed findings of soon to be published
research with colleagues at the Centre of Excellence for Cognition and its
Disorders. It indicates that genes are the most important determinant of maths
and reading skills among schoolchildren. Their study of twins’ NAPLAN
performance apparently found that maths, reading and spelling skills are up to
75 per cent genetic and writing skills are about 50 per cent genetic. The
influence of schools and teachers, the focus of Labor’s policies, accounts for
only about 5 per cent of performance.
Social psychologist
Richard Nisbett was more hopeful in his assessment of the nature versus nurture
debate in education. In Intelligence and How to Get It, he analyses
research on various interventions to improve the educational outcomes of
children from poor backgrounds. Some appeared promising, but many had only a modest
impact whose effect diminished.
Recent research
suggesting academic performance is substantially heritable challenges existing
literature in which academics and politicians extol the benefits of government
interventions to redress educational inequality. But it could be used
constructively to drive policy reforms that provide greater choice in school
and university education to cater to inborn differences…… [my red bolding]
There we have it in a nutshell - genes are destiny, a second-tier education system is advisable and anyone who suggests otherwise is suffering from pathological envy.
However, the journalist wasn't being as honest as possible concerning the views of Emeritus Professor Brian Byrne.
Here are two quotes from the answers he gave the Insight program moderator when questioned about that international twin study, which included twins from the Sydney area:
JENNY BROCKIE: This is what's genetic,
what's inherited?
PROFESSOR BRYAN BYRNE: What's genetic, for the NAPLAN
varies between about 50 and 75 percent of the differences amongst children's
performance can be traced back to genetic differences which leaves a fair bit
for the environment…..
JENNY BROCKIE: And genes aren't destiny
Bryan we need to make that very clear?
PROFESSOR BRYAN BYRNE: That's right.
Nor does the journalist specifically mention that Professor Dr. Richard Nisbett has formed a view that genetics matters less than differences in family environment and culture when it comes to intelligence and educational outcomes.
Nor does the journalist specifically mention that Professor Dr. Richard Nisbett has formed a view that genetics matters less than differences in family environment and culture when it comes to intelligence and educational outcomes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)