On
5 April 2022 the Liberal
Party of Australia (NSW Division) Executive was composed of:
State President Philip Ruddock, State Director (in attendance) Chris
Stone, Urban Vice-Presidents Penny George, Country
and Regional Vice-Presidents Tobias Lehmann & Aileen MacDonald
Female Vice-President Mary-Lou Jarvis, Young Liberal President De Yi
Wu, Leader
of the Federal Parliamentary Party Scott Morrison MP (and from time to time his representative Alex Hawke MP), Leader of the
State Parliamentary Party Dominic Perrottet MP, Urban Representatives James
Wallace, Matthew Hana, Chantelle Fornari-Orsmond, Martin Zaiter, Sally
Betts, Zac Miles, Michelle Byrne, Sammy Elmir & Jacqui Munro
(replacing Matthew Camenzuli who was expelled from the Liberal Party
on or about 6 April 2022 for bringing the legal action, Camenzuli
v Morrison), Country Representatives Michelle Bishop, Patrick
Doherty, Mark Croxford, James Owen, Chair of Convention Committee and
Director of Policy Engagement Alex Dore and Treasurer Mark Baillie.
A
battle had been brewing for some time between the Federal Liberal
Party Executive, the NSW Liberal Party Executive and state local party
branches over the 2018 changes to the NSW
Division Constitution which included the right to state
branch plebiscites. These changes also allowed the federal leader of
the Liberal Party a guaranteed seat on the executive.
The
first hint of factional fighting and preselection battles came to
light in the local government arena with Diaz
v Ruddock; Attie v Ruddock and Zaiter
v Ruddock in July 2021.
The
open stoush widened and had developed by February 2022 into Camenzuli
v Hawke. Followed by Morrison
& Ors v Camenzuli & Ors; Attorney-General of the
Commonwealth v Camenzuli & Ors, heard by the High
Court of Australia in March 2022. The High Court remitted the case to
its jurisdiction and then promptly remitted it back to NSW Court of
Appeal – given that no difficulty was found to exist in the hearing
schedule in the state court.
On
5 April 2022 in Camenzuli
v Morrison the NSW Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, ruled
that the Federal Liberal Party Executive had the power to intervene
in the NSW Division’s candidate preselection process and take
control of the selection of candidates.
The
12 electorates in question being Farrer, Mitchell,
North Sydney, Hughes, Parramatta, Fowler,
Grayndler, Newcastle, Warringah, Greenway,
Eden-Monaro and McMahon. Candidate selection and
endorsement was by a three person federal committee comprising Scott
Morrison, Alex Hawke and Trent Zimmerman and
occurred ahead of the 5 April judgment.
Subsequent
to the 5 April judgment Morrison
ordered the expulsion of Matthew Camenzuli from the
Liberal Party. Mr. Camenzuli is appealing this expulsion.
Legal
proceedings in the matter of the usurped state candidate preselection
process has not gone away however.
In
MATTHEW CAMENZULI v THE HON. SCOTT MORRISON MP First
Respondent, CHRISTINE McDIVEN AM Second Respondent, THE HON. DOMINIC
PERROTTET MP Third Respondent, THE HON. ALEX HAWKE MP Fourth
Respondent, THE HON. SUSSAN LEY MP Fifth Respondent, TRENT ZIMMERMAN
MP Sixth Respondent, THE HON. PHILIP RUDDOCK AO Seventh Respondent,
THE HON. JOHN OLSEN AO Eighth Respondent on 7 April 2022 the
High Court of Australia decided the timetable for hearing of oral
arguments in this Special Leave To Appeal Application, commencing 4pm
on Friday 8 April 2022.
Apparently
Morrison et al intend to argue that Camenzuli no longer has standing
before the Court as he is not now a member of the Liberal Party and
will ask that the application be dismissed.
Scott Morrison's dysfunctional need to control every aspect of the Liberal Party of Australia is ripping this 77 year-old conservative political party apart in a very public manner.